The Playbook›Tools and tech stack›ChatGPT, Claude or Copilot? How to choose AI tools for your firm

ChatGPT, Claude or Copilot? How to choose AI tools for your firm

The short answer

Pick one general AI assistant as your firm standard, on a business plan with proper data controls. Choose based on where your team already works (Microsoft or Google), what data settings you need, and which one your team actually likes using. Then check what AI your existing systems already include before buying more.

Key takeaways

  • Standardise on one general assistant, not five.
  • Business plans matter for data control and admin.
  • Check the AI already built into your existing software.
  • Run a two-week side-by-side test on your real tasks.

Stop comparing feature lists

The big AI assistants leapfrog each other every few months. If you choose on today's feature list, you'll want to switch again next quarter. Choose on things that don't change as fast: data controls, admin, cost, and fit with how your team works.

What to actually compare

  • Data settings: can you stop your inputs being used for training at an account level?
  • Admin: can you add and remove staff and see usage?
  • Integration: does it work well with Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, whichever you use?
  • Quality on your tasks: test it on your own emails, notes and reviews.
  • Cost per seat, and whether everyone needs a seat on day one.
Free: AI Tool Stack Guide for PracticesWhich AI tools are worth paying for in a small to mid-sized firm, what each is good at, and where they overlap.
Get it free

Run a fair test

Pick five real (anonymised) tasks from last month. Run them through two or three tools. Have the people who do that work score the output. You'll usually get a clear winner, and your team will have bought into the choice.

The best AI tool is the one your team actually opens on a Tuesday afternoon.Hayden Walsh

Common mistakes

  • Letting every staff member choose their own tool.
  • Paying for seats nobody uses.
  • Ignoring the AI already inside your ledger or practice management software.

Questions accountants ask

Is the free version good enough?

For personal experimenting, maybe. For client work, use a business plan so you control the data settings.

Should we build our own AI tool?

Almost never at the start. Get value from off-the-shelf tools first. Custom builds make sense once you know exactly which workflow you're optimising.

Want the AI Tool Stack Guide for Practices?Free. Takes 10 seconds.
Get it free
Hayden Walsh
Hayden Walsh

Chartered Accountant · Founder, Off Balance

Chartered Accountant with a background at Deloitte and Xero, plus years in sales, leadership and startups. Hayden helps accounting firms across New Zealand and Australia work out where AI fits, then actually put it to work.

More about Hayden →

Straight from Hayden

Practical AI for accountants, every week on LinkedIn.

Follow on LinkedIn